When Penn State fans celebrated the arrival of two of the nation’s most highly touted recruits last winter, many believed the Nittany Lions had just secured the future of their program. Both players — a five-star wide receiver and a five-star edge rusher — were ranked among the top 20 prospects nationally and were expected to contribute immediately under head coach James Franklin. Instead, four games into the season, the story has taken a dramatically different turn. Neither player has lived up to the immense expectations, and their struggles have left coaches and fans alike scratching their heads.
The wide receiver, hailed as one of the most explosive offensive weapons in the 2025 recruiting class, was supposed to transform Penn State’s passing game overnight. But through the first month of the season, he’s caught only five passes for 38 yards and has yet to find the end zone. Coaches say he’s having trouble grasping the playbook and often looks lost in route execution. “It’s not about talent — we know he’s got that,” one offensive assistant told local reporters. “The problem is confidence and consistency. He’s second-guessing himself on every snap.” What was expected to be a breakout freshman campaign has instead become a frustrating series of missed opportunities.
On the other side of the ball, the edge rusher’s situation is just as concerning. Billed as a future All-American, the 6’5”, 260-pound freshman has struggled to adjust to the speed and physicality of Big Ten football. Once dominant in high school, he’s been neutralized by veteran offensive tackles and often pushed off the line with ease. In four games, he has recorded just three tackles and no sacks. “It’s like he forgot how to play,” a defensive teammate admitted anonymously. “We all know how good he is, but something isn’t clicking. He’s overthinking every move instead of just reacting.”
James Franklin, known for his ability to develop young talent, has addressed the issue publicly but carefully. During his weekly press conference, he defended both players and cautioned fans against writing them off too soon. “Freshmen sometimes need time — even five-stars,” Franklin said. “The transition from high school to college football is huge. The talent is there, but they have to trust themselves and trust the process. We’re confident they’ll figure it out.” Despite his reassurance, the coaching staff has quietly reduced their snap counts in recent weeks to relieve pressure and help them regain confidence.
Behind the scenes, sources close to the program suggest that both players are struggling not just on the field but mentally as well. The wide receiver, in particular, is said to be dealing with the weight of expectations from fans and family, while the defensive standout is reportedly frustrated with his lack of playing time and has considered entering the transfer portal if things don’t improve. Coaches are working closely with the team’s sports psychology staff to keep their confidence intact and help them regain their focus.
Teammates, meanwhile, are trying to rally around the duo. Veteran players have taken them under their wings, emphasizing that early struggles don’t define a career. “I remember my freshman year — it was rough,” said senior linebacker Abdul Carter. “You come in thinking you’re going to dominate right away, but the game humbles you. What matters is how you respond. These guys have all the tools, they just need to reset mentally and attack every rep like it’s a new start.” The message is clear: the team still believes in their potential, even if the results haven’t shown yet.
For now, Penn State’s season continues with both players still trying to find their footing. The hype that once surrounded their arrivals has cooled, but there’s still plenty of time to turn things around. If they can learn from these early challenges and rediscover the talent that made them five-star recruits in the first place, they could still become the stars fans expected. But until then, the story remains one of unfulfilled promise — and a cautionary reminder that not every high school superstar becomes an instant college sensation.
Leave a Reply