The Ohio State Buckeyes have long been a cornerstone of college football excellence, producing some of the greatest players to ever step on the gridiron. From Heisman Trophy winners to Super Bowl champions, the legacy is rich, and the debates are endless. Recently, a panel of former players, coaches, and analysts came together to assemble what they believe is the definitive All-Time Ohio State Team. What followed was a selection that stirred pride, nostalgia, and plenty of controversy.
At quarterback, the choice was a tug-of-war between Troy Smith and Justin Fields, but in the end, Smith edged it out. His Heisman-winning 2006 season and leadership skills gave him the nod, though many fans argued Fields’ modern dominance and near-perfect seasons deserved the spot. Current head coach Ryan Day admitted that even he leaned toward Fields, but said Smith’s ability to lift the team during a transformative era could not be overlooked.
Running back proved less controversial. Archie Griffin, the only two-time Heisman winner in college football history, was the first name on the list. To complement him, Ezekiel Elliott was chosen for his legendary postseason heroics in 2014 that brought Ohio State a national title. That pairing symbolized both the historic roots and the modern power of the program. Some fans expected Eddie George to be slotted alongside Griffin, and his exclusion sparked heated debate across Buckeye Nation.
The wide receiver unit featured names that felt like a dream team. Cris Carter, perhaps the most technically gifted pass-catcher Ohio State has ever produced, led the group. He was joined by Michael Thomas, whose NFL dominance proved the Buckeyes’ ability to develop all-time greats beyond college. Rounding it out was David Boston, a record-setter who embodied the flash and swagger of Ohio State football in the 1990s. Leaving out recent stars like Marvin Harrison Jr. was tough, but the panel insisted that longevity and legacy carried more weight than current hype.
On the defensive side, the selections were just as jaw-dropping. At defensive end, the dynamic Chase Young and the legendary Joey Bosa created a nightmare pass-rush duo. Linebacker featured Chris Spielman, one of the toughest and most beloved Buckeyes, alongside James Laurinaitis, whose consistency made him a fan favorite. In the secondary, Jack Tatum, known as the “Assassin,” provided hard-hitting intimidation, while Malcolm Jenkins brought leadership and versatility. Some argued that Shawn Springs should have made the final cut, but his name landed on the honorable mentions list instead.
Special teams were also recognized, with Mike Nugent securing the kicker spot for his reliability under pressure, and A.J. Trapasso earning the punter role. The return specialist was Ted Ginn Jr., whose blazing speed and electrifying kickoff returns were game-changers throughout his Ohio State career. Even Ryan Day joked that if Ginn had been healthy in the 2007 BCS Championship game, the Buckeyes might have shocked the Florida Gators.
As the roster went public, reactions poured in from fans, alumni, and media across the country. Some saw it as a fitting tribute to generations of greatness, while others were furious that certain names were left out. That is the beauty of Ohio State football: the history is so deep, the legends so numerous, that no all-time list can satisfy everyone. But one thing is certain—whether it is Griffin or Elliott, Carter or Thomas, Young or Bosa, the Ohio State Buckeyes remain a program defined by greatness, and this All-Time Team is a testament to the dynasty they built.
Leave a Reply